I never played with the guy and neither did you. What I can tell you are the things that his teammates have said about him and the inspiration he provided to the team in '08. Brandon Spikes said that Tebow was the reason he came back after his Jr year.
When a coach of Urban's stature gushes about his leadership capabilities you have to take note.
If Tebow doesn't make it at QB, he'll make it somewhere. Belichick likes him.
It's rare when you get Bill Belichick to talk to the press, but when asked "is it feasible to put him at other positions?", he replied:
”My sense of Tim Tebow is, if you asked him to play nose, he’d play nose (tackle). I think he’s that kind of kid. Whatever you ask him to do, he’d do,” Belichick said. ”I don’t know what a team would do with him, but I think he’s a real interesting player. He’s had a great career. It speaks for itself. Second leading passer in SEC history, whatever it is. He’s had tremendous production. They hardly ever lose.”
The next question: "What else do you like about him?"
”There’s a lot to like,” Belichick answered.