JimmyNoodles

Cook's production from the 2023 season to the 2024 season is basically the same...except for scoring. He had a terrific year last year in that regard, up from 6 in 2023 to 18TDs in 2024. Is this the new norm? Are we expecting 15 TDs a year from Cook? The likelihood that this past year is a career year for him in that regard seems greater to me than this is the new norm. Maybe he has one more year close to this? If Cook were maxxed out as a player, I would see him in the Alvin Kamara mold. If Cook was hauling in 60+ receptions a year in addition to his rushing production, his case would be a lot stronger. As it is, with his usage, 10m a year seems generous.

Everyone wants a trade chip. Here you go.

This is how a good organization is run. Beane and McD are going to discuss what the needs are and how they are going to approach the roster. But, who ultimately has the final say if there's a disagreement such as you outline? I'm putting my money on McD.

Yes 10000000% but is that going to happen? Would McD give up control? He likes what he likes. I don't hink he's going to let someone retool "his" defense. I think you'll see minor tweaks in an effort to make it look like someting is being done.

I would totally agree with this, but I don't think that Beane drafts anyone on D without McD input. And, that's how it should be. Keeps people on the same page. Does Beane just need different marching orders?

There is not one person the DL that should feel they have an automatic spot on this team. It's time to cut bait, just like they did with Diggs. It's open season on D lineman. People need pay cuts, trade, or move on, however it happens. I would leave the offense folks alone. They finally got the line right. Need one speed receiver.

But really, it’s all the time.

Congrats to Josh! Certainly could have won this award sooner, but better late than never. One of the all-time greats at QB and we are lucky to get to see him play. I imagine he'll stay loyal to the organization and I really hope that pays off for him with a championship.

This is what is called a PROCESS. McD is working on getting this down to 32PPG.

Every year they come up small. Just rotate the offenders. Most everyone takes a turn. Truth is, the Bills are a very flawed team, led a flawed front office. Rinse and repeat.

For the love of God, please blow it up already. How many more reruns are needed? We already lose every year to good teams.

Yes McD has to go…as of 2 years ago. With that said there’s lots of screw ups today.

Besides Josh, if the Bills win the SB this year, it’s all about the Oline. They have been dominating.

We had KC on the ropes last year by halftime. I remember an endzone shot of their defense almost at the half where you could see the players faces and they were exhausted. Second half they adjusted and started coming up to stop the run. We did not. We should have run a ton of play action at that point and I believe we could have won fairly easily.

Absolutely. I had total confidence at that point the Josh would have got points to end the game. I’ll also give McD props for the field goal decision since it put us up 8. The Ravens needing 2 saved the day.