Fine, I'll say it. He is a top 10 qb.
Look at what he's had to work with at receiver last year and this year.
Look at how crappy the pass protection is with this o-line.
They took away any deep threats, thereby negating one of his best weapons.
He's had to work with a different coordinator every year he's been here. And this year, we've got another run, run, pass specialist.
His scrambling ability is the best in the league.
He rarely makes big mistakes in terms of turnovers.
All of these things factored in, I'd place him as a top 10 qb.
Fans who trash him just don't watch other QBs with the same critical eye.