In both 2003 and 2002, Sigler earned second team All-Big Sky Conference honors as an offensive tackle and first team Verizon Academic All-District VIII honors. He was also named to the Big Sky Conference All-Academic team for the third time as a senior in 2004. He was chosen to play in four different college all-star games and played in two – the 65th Blue-Gray Game and The Villages Gridiron Classic.